Find thoughtful Christmas gifts and holiday gift ideas at Caldwell Gifts. Explore our Christmas collection for inspiration as you shop for friends, family, and the special people on your list.

Whether you're planning ahead or looking for one more thoughtful surprise, discover gifts to help make your holiday giving feel personal.

537 products

Two's Company Santa Vanilla Marshmallow Scented Lip Balm
$7.99
$7.99
Mudpie Christmas Tree Needle Point Stocking Ornament
$13.99
$13.99
Mudpie Santa Needle Point Stocking Ornament
$13.99
$13.99
Mudpie Nutcracker Needle Point Stocking Ornament
$13.99
$13.99
Mudpie Snowman Needle Point Stocking Ornament
$13.99
$13.99
Mudpie Everly Tree Light-Up Plush Pal
$34.99
$34.99
Mudpie Saint Nick Light-Up Plush Pal
$34.99
$34.99
Mudpie Jingle The Reindeer Jumbo Plush Pal
$227.99
$227.99
Carmie's Kitchen Feliz Mexicano Dip And Cheese ball Mix
$5.99
$5.99
Carmie's Kitchen Parmesan Noel Dip And Cheese ball Mix
$5.99
$5.99
Carmie's Kitchen Christmas Pickle Dip And Cheese ball Mix
$5.99
$5.99
Carmie's Kitchen Classic Chocolate Hot Cocoa
$12.99
$12.99
Carmie's Kitchen Mulling Spice Spiced Cider Mix
$12.99
$12.99
Decorative ornament with 'Merry Merry' text on a beige background
The Darling Effect Scalloped Round Picture Frame Ornament
$12.99
$12.99
A glossy hair claw clip with a red, black, and white plaid pattern, shown on a solid tan background.
The Darling Effect Evergreen Plaid Claw Clip
$12.99
$12.99
Plaid and polka dot scarf on a beige background
The Darling Effect Twirl & Tie Scarf Accessory
$12.99
$12.99
A pink waffle tea towel with a festive Christmas print, wrapped in a white paper band that reads 'Vintage Sheets'. The towel is displayed flat against a solid beige background.
The Darling Effect Mistletoe Magic Waffle Tea Towel
$16.99
$16.99
A festive Christmas-themed keychain bag featuring a round dark green faux leather pouch, a red and green plaid ribbon bow, gold-tone metal hardware, a pearl bead, a green Christmas tree charm, and a teddy bear charm, set against a solid beige background.
The Darling Effect Travel Jewelry Case Bag Charm - Pine & Plaid
$17.99
$17.99
A clear acrylic keychain featuring an illustrated cream-colored teddy bear with a dark green bow, attached to gold-tone metal hardware including a key ring, lobster clasp, and a round branded tag that reads 'the thing direct'.
The Darling Effect Acrylic Keychain - Teddy Bear Theo
$9.99
$9.99
A teddy bear-shaped keychain with a gold-tone split ring and clasp, featuring a cream-colored bear body, a black ribbon bow, and a small gold bell, set against a solid beige background.
The Darling Effect Teddy Bear Theo Mirror Bag Charm
$17.99
$17.99
A small zippered coin purse with a green and white striped beaded background and a central teddy bear motif in tan, cream, and dark green. The purse has a gold-tone ring attachment and a decorative bead charm, photographed on a solid peach-beige background.
The Darling Effect Beaded Teddy Bear Theo Handcrafted Beaded Pouch
$32.99
$32.99
A dark teal green teddy fleece cosmetic pouch featuring an embroidered brown teddy bear with a black ribbon and white pearl embellishments, set against a light gray marble background.
The Darling Effect Teddy Bear Theo Teddy Pouch
$30.99
$30.99
Person wearing cozy slippers sitting on a bed with a green ottoman in the background.
The Darling Effect Dreamy Daze Slippers - Teddy Bear
$30.99
$30.99
A woman wearing a light pink crewneck sweatshirt with red ribbed trim and 'holly jolly' text in red and gold across the chest, paired with blue jeans, against a solid tan background.
The Darling Effect Signature Crew Holly Jolly
$64.99
$64.99
A light heather gray crewneck sweatshirt featuring the word 'MERRY' in dark green varsity-style letters with a red bow graphic underneath, laid flat on a warm tan background.
The Darling Effect Mockneck Sweatshirt - Merry Bow
$55.99
$55.99
Green blanket with red floral pattern and red ribbon on a beige background
The Darling Effect A Merry Moment Snuggle Up Plush Blanket
$50.99
$50.99
Beige sneaker with a red and white checkered bow and matching scrunchie on a beige background
The Darling Effect Gingham Red Step It Up Shoelaces
$10.99
$10.99
A round green tree skirt with a white and green floral pattern, featuring a scalloped edge and a central hole tied with a white ribbon.
Laura Park Designs Dorset Garden Tree Skirt
$118.99
$118.99
A round, scalloped-edge fabric tree skirt featuring a colorful floral and horseshoe pattern on a white background.
Laura Park Designs Giverny Tree Skirt
$118.99
$118.99
Green Christmas stocking with yellow floral pattern on a white background
Laura Park Designs Rosemary Meadow Christmas Stocking
$61.99
$61.99
A Christmas stocking with a green velvet cuff and hanging loop, featuring a pink and green circular medallion pattern on a white background.
Laura Park Designs Rosie Christmas Stocking
$61.99
$61.99
Wooden toy train with colorful cars on a white background
Two's Company Santa 3 PC Wooden Magnetic Train Set
$21.99
$21.99
A clear plastic bag of marshmallows tied with a white bow and red ribbon, printed with snowman faces, with three small marshmallows placed in front on a white background.
Two's Company Snowman Marshmallow Candy
$12.99
$12.99
Tissues printed with as a rectangular gift box wrapped in festive red and white patterned paper, tied with a large red ribbon and bow, and decorated with green holly leaves and berries, shown on a plain white background.
Boston International Pocket Tissues - A Present For You
$5.99
$5.99
Hand-painted Christmas tree with 'Merry Christmas' text on a beige background
Boston International Cocktail Napkins-Gilded Painterly Tree
$7.99
$7.99
A festive Christmas tree illustration made from green pine and fir branches, red berries, and a gold star, centered on a light cream patterned background.
Boston International Guest Napkins - Christmas Branches Tree
$9.99
$9.99
A square wooden picture frame with a natural oak-like finish, decorated with a glossy red bow at the top. The frame holds a black-and-white photo of a family, and a small white nameplate is visible in the lower right corner of the insert.
Mudpie Small Red Bow Wood Frame
$27.99
$27.99
A white ceramic vase with a gold angel outline decoration on the front and a gold rim at the top, shown on a plain white background.
Mudpie Gold Angel Vase
$15.99
$15.99
A rustic metal angel Christmas ornament with a peach-colored head, silver wings, and black snowflake designs on a white body, hanging from a jute string.
Mudpie Snowflake Angel Ornament
$10.99
$10.99
A Christmas-themed needlepoint canvas bag with a gold rope handle, featuring a stitched Santa Claus face on a dark green background with holly accents. A brown gift card is tucked inside the top opening, which is labeled 'GIFT CARD'.
Mudpie Santa Needlepoint Gift Card
$9.99
$9.99
A small cross-stitch gift card holder featuring a nutcracker design and pink bows on a cream fabric background, with a gold rope handle and a brown backing card labeled 'GIFT CARD'.
Mudpie Nutcracker Needlepoint Gift Card Pouch
$9.99
$9.99
A festive Christmas art print featuring a painted green evergreen tree with white snow-like accents and the words 'Merry Christmas' in white script over a textured beige background.
Boston International Guest Napkins - Gilded Painterly Tree
$9.99
$9.99
A square white knitted Christmas ornament or decorative piece featuring a reindeer face with black embroidered eyes, a red fabric nose, and white antlers with red dashed stitching, shown on a plain white background.
Mudpie Reindeer Christmas Potholder
$11.99
$11.99
A crocheted holiday wreath-shaped doily or coaster with a dark green scalloped border, a white center, and red stitched accents and bow details, shown on a plain white background.
Mudpie Wreath Crochet Trivet
$15.99
$15.99
Children's Tea Set including tea pitcher, teacups, saucers, and sugar and creamer set with Santa and reindeer in a red and white striped box on a white background.
Mudpie Holly Jolly Tea Set
$26.99
$26.99
A baby shower ornament shaped like a stroller, featuring a pink glitter canopy and two matching pink glitter wheels, presented in a brown kraft gift box with a white ribbon and gold 'Baby's First Christmas' text.
Mudpie Baby's First Christmas Stroller Ornament - Pink
$12.99
$12.99
Two Christmas-themed ceramic plates on a white background. One round plate features a green and white checkered border, a red bow, and an illustration of a sleigh carrying green pine branches and red gifts.
Mudpie Farm Nested Set
$65.99
$65.99
A crocheted square pot holder designed to look like a wrapped gift, featuring a dark green body with a red bow and red cross-section representing the wrapping ribbon, shown on a plain white background.
Mudpie Christmas Present Trivet
$15.99
$15.99
A hand-painted ceramic angel Christmas ornament with a pale green dress, translucent wings, a peach-colored head, and a green wreath with red berries at the waist, hanging from a twine loop.
Mudpie Wreath Angel Ornament
$10.99
$10.99
Hand painted angel ceramic Christmas Tree Ornament on a white background. Angel is wearing a pale blue dress with green holly leaves and red berries. Angel has a hand-drawn look with out facial features.
Mudpie Holly Angel Ornament
$10.99
$10.99